11 Best Whiskeys Marking America’s 250th Anniversary

America’s 250th birthday is pulling whiskey makers in two directions at once: some are digging into archives and heritage mashbills, others are building something new for the occasion. The range runs from a $20 Beam release to a 50-state bourbon blend five years in the making. Here’s what’s hitting shelves.

Lost Lantern United States of Bourbon Cask Strength

Independent bottler Lost Lantern spent more than five years assembling this project. Co-founders Adam Polonski and Nora Ganley-Roper traveled the country to personally vet a bourbon from every state, then blended the results into three expressions. The 100 Proof release ($79.99) and cask-strength edition ($99.99) share the same 50-state blend, with component whiskeys ranging two to 10 years old. The 1776 Edition ($199.99) narrows the field to bourbon from the original 13 colonies, bottled at 121.4 proof and limited to 1,776 hand-numbered bottles. Every contributing distillery is printed on the label, consistent with Lost Lantern’s transparency-first approach — from established names like New Riff and Balcones down to craft producers younger than the project itself.

The cask-strength expression opens dense and buttery on the nose, with caramel fudge, waffle cone, cornbread, brûléed brown sugar and oatmeal raisin cookies. The palate coats the tongue and drinks hot, layering creamy caramel over a grainy character that splits the difference between rye and wheat, plus a mineral streak, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, banana bread, chestnut, plum, brandied cherries, almond, leather and mint. The finish turns toasty and dark, moving through cracked pepper and banana walnut muffin into cherry, raisin and plum before settling on leather and spice. It’s a complex bourbon that rewards picking apart flavor by flavor, and the blending effort behind it shows in the glass.

Click here to read our review.

WhistlePig Rye, White & Blue PiggyBank

WhistlePig dressed up its 10 Year Straight Rye for the occasion, bottling this edition at 110 proof and packaging it in a collectible PiggyBank decanter. At $249.99, it’s positioned as a display piece as much as a pour — the same rye that built WhistlePig’s reputation, turned up in both proof and presentation.

The nose packs in spice — sassafras, clove, pine, cinnamon, nutmeg, dill, mint — against sweeter maple, cola and browned butter. On the palate, spice takes the lead again with nutmeg, cinnamon, clove, spearmint and dill, but oak runs underneath the whole way, and that browned butter note returns to add texture. The finish is medium in length and herbaceous up front, dill and spearmint and eucalyptus, with brown sugar sweetness drifting in and out before spice and sweet oak take the last word. It’s a well-balanced rye that backs up WhistlePig’s reputation in the category. Buy it here.

Click here to read our review.

WhistlePig Declaration Wheat Whiskey

A lighter counterpoint to WhistlePig’s rye-heavy lineup, Declaration is distilled from a high-wheat mashbill, double aged in new American oak, and bottled at 86 proof. It retails for $73.99 and arrives topped with a cracked Liberty Bell design tied to the Fourth of July.

The nose is tame — hay, cream, apple and nutmeg, with a touch of blueberry and elderflower. The palate is thin to moderate, where oak and tannin meet wheat bread, blueberry pie, chestnut, coffee and lemon peel. The finish mixes biscuit, pepper and coffee grounds. This one sits outside WhistlePig’s strongest work, but it’s a light, easy sipper suited to summer drinking and a solid pick for a Fourth of July pour. Buy it here.

Click here to read our review.

Rittenhouse 10-Year 250th Anniversary Rye

Heaven Hill’s new limited Rittenhouse release leans into Pennsylvania’s rye history as much as the national anniversary. It’s Bottled-in-Bond at 100 proof, aged 10 years, priced at $100, and wrapped in Liberty Bell-themed packaging — a pairing that makes sense given rye’s roots in the state.

Sagamore America 250 Straight Rye

Sagamore kept this one small: just 250 numbered bottles, sold only at its Baltimore waterfront distillery starting mid-July, each paired with a commemorative coin. The eight-year-old Maryland-style rye is built on Sagamore’s double mashbill and bottled at 110 proof, with notes of caramel, citrus zest, hazelnut, honey, dried cherry and baked apple. At $125, it’s a distillery-exclusive aimed squarely at collectors already tracking the brand.

Knob Creek 9 Year Old: Independence Edition

The liquid here is unchanged from standard Knob Creek 9 Year — nine years in American white oak, bottled at 100 proof, with the brand’s usual vanilla, caramel and charred oak profile. What’s new is the packaging: a blue wax seal, the first color change in the brand’s history, on a red-white-and-blue label. Buy it here.

Buzzard’s Roost Red, White & Roost Double Oak Bourbon

This single-barrel release comes from a custom-toasted barrel hand-selected by co-founder Jason Brauner, bottled at barrel strength (111.8 proof) with a 75% corn, 21% rye, 4% malted barley mashbill. Expect vanilla crème brûlée and malted caramel on the nose, with butterscotch and orange zest on the palate. It’s priced at $84.99. Buy it here.

Blue Run USA 250th Anniversary Commemorative Packaging

Blue Run built this release around its High Rye Kentucky Straight Bourbon, a small-batch expression bottled at 111 proof with praline, orange peel and stone fruit running through the nose and palate. The commemorative packaging is the real story: a navy Viceroy butterfly with white star accents, a red-and-white striped tax strip, and labels printed in 22K gold ink. It’s $89.99 and lands in select markets including California, Florida, Texas and Ohio.

Bulleit 20-Year-Old Rye

Bulleit’s oldest rye release to date pushes its signature 95% rye mashbill through two decades of aging, cask strength, in a blend from Nicole Austin, Diageo’s director of American whiskey liquid development. The outturn is capped at 1,776 bottles — a nod to the anniversary.

Old Overholt 250th Edition

Overholt’s contribution stays close to its roots: a 4-year, 86-proof bottling with a historically styled, patriotic label, tied to its standing as the longest continuously maintained American whiskey brand, dating to 1810. At $20, it’s also the cheapest bottle here, though distribution is tight — Pennsylvania, Ohio, Oregon, Maryland and New Orleans only.

The nose leans grain-forward, cereal and Raisin Bran with cinnamon. The palate is thin to moderate, delivering a punch of cinnamon and nutmeg with a touch of dill, brown sugar and tapioca. The finish is quick, gingerbread and cinnamon fading fast. This is a decent young rye whose main selling point is the collectible packaging rather than what’s in the glass.

Click here to read our review.

Peg Leg Porker Spirit of America

Peg Leg Porker’s entry carries the Bottled-in-Bond designation, setting it apart from most of the commemorative field. The release ties back to founder Carey Bringle, who lost a leg to osteogenic sarcoma at 17 and went on to build both a barbecue brand and a bourbon label — reportedly the only pitmaster with award-winning credentials in both.

America 250 whiskeyThe nose is muted, offering cranberry, mint and a touch of ethanol. The palate is where the smoke shows up: smoked wood and barbecue smoke lead, backed by dark chocolate, caramel, coffee grounds and blueberry. Hickory and charcoal take over on the finish, delivering an ashy, tobacco-heavy close. It starts sweet and turns bitter and ashy fast — distinctive, though the char can run heavy.

Click here to read our review.